Best Rowing Machine Reviews for 2021

Share on pinterest
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on email
heydayDo Affiliate Links Disclosure

In this article I provide product evaluations for several of the most popular rowing machines designed for home use currently on the market here in 2020.

I also share my opinion on what models I consider to be the best for each of the three main rowing resistance types: water, air, & magnetic.

 

Table of Contents

A total-body cardio workout at home

Exercise time spent on a rowing machine can provide you with a better full-body workout than many other pieces of cardio equipment, be they treadmills, ellipticals, exercise bikes or stepper machines.

All of the major muscle groups are activated during the course of a single (properly executed) stroke:

  • biceps
  • triceps
  • shoulders
  • upper back & lats
  • core & abs
  • glutes
  • hamstrings
  • quadriceps
  • & calves

And rowing at home provides you with all of its cardiovascular & muscular benefits at your convenience.

 

What’s ahead

In this article I write reviews of 6 popular home rowing machines I tracked down locally that are available online everywhere.

All of these models offer free shipping at Amazon as of this writing, which is nice since they’re heavy.

I also provide information, pros & cons, etc., regarding the four different types of resistance that are built into rowing machines:

  • air resistance
  • water resistance
  • magnetic resistance
  • hydraulic resistance

And I include a brief overview & video on how to properly perform the rowing stroke.

 

If you’re interested in improving your rowing skill…

…I’ve written an article here on heydayDo that features tutorial videos with tips on proper form and on avoiding common rowing mistakes.

It also shows you the different muscle groups that are activated during each part of the rowing stroke.

You can click here to read it in another tab.

 

 

test tubes orange - heydayDo icon

Science resources included

As is my custom here on heydayDo, I will provide links to all of the relevant sports science & medical resources, clinical studies, and nutritional data used in this article.

 

 

The rowing machines reviewed in this article

Concept2 Model D in use - heydayDo image

 

Here are the home rowing machines I evaluated for this article, starting with my three favorites:

Best air rower & best rowing machine overall

Concept 2 Model D4.9, 5000+ owner reviews

*Top-rated rowing machine is the home rower of choice of dedicated fitness enthusiasts, CrossFitters, as well as pro, college, & Olympic athletes.

 

Best rowing machine with water resistance

Water Rower Club Ash Wood – 4.6 , 800+ reviews

*Premium hand-built wood rower is quiet, long-lasting, & attractive.

 

Best magnetic resistance rowing machine

Fitness Reality 4000MR 4.8 , 30+ reviews (introduced in 2019)

*Great warranty & design, comes with nice programmable workouts too.

 

I also “test-drove” these rowing machines, and include my product reviews for each of them here too:

Schwinn Crewmaster 4.2 , 100+ reviews

Stamina Avari4.1 , 200+ reviews

Lifespan RW10003.7 , 100+ reviews

 

rowing machine green - heydayDo icon

 

Protect Your Investment

Do you need an exercise equipment mat to protect your floor from your home rowing machine?

A good mat also keeps floor dust or carpet fibers from getting into your equipment’s moving parts and causing problems.

I wrote a buyer’s guide & article on the better equipment mats available for both carpet & hardwood floors here.

 

Proper Rowing Form

If you’re just starting out, please make sure you use correct form on a rowing machine.

Due to the repetitive nature of cardio machines, poor technique and bad posture can easily give you the injury blues.

Here’s a nice in-depth tutorial video courtesy of Concept2 Australia:

 


 

Best Rowing Machine Reviews

Concept2 Model D- the best rowing machine in the world - heydayDo image

 

#1 Overall Best Home Rower

Concept2 Model D Indoor Rowing Machine

Owner satisfaction rating 99% 4.9⭐, 5,000+ online reviews

If your plan is to get a home rowing machine and then get busy with a consistent workout plan, then I encourage you to give the Concept2 Model D serious consideration.

Concept2 Model D Indoor Rowing Machine copy

There’s a reason there are so many Concept 2 Model D’s & E’s in professional & collegiate sports teams’ training rooms, CrossFit® Boxes, commercial gyms…and in the home gyms of athletes everywhere:

 

They are designed & built to deliver all the benefits of a REAL rowing machine’s full body cardio workout.

And they’re tough as nails.

 

If you’re serious about working out

Inexpensive rowing machines are not built to handle the heavy usage that dedicated fitness people are looking for.

Just look at how short the parts warranties are for any cheap rowing machine; most offer 90 days.

On the other hand, the Concept2 Model D is definitely up to the task if you intend to put in the effort.

They provide 2 years of protection for the parts and 5 years for the frame.

 

Got muscle?

And if you are already used to working out and have at least some muscle tone, I sincerely believe you would burn through 5 or more of the $200-$400 cheap rowing machines before your Model D would need anything other than a little oil on its chain.

 

What I like about the Concept2

 

Concept2 owner satisfaction rating is excellent

This may be the highest-rated piece of fitness equipment available on Amazon or anywhere.

I found over 5,000 owner reviews from across the online universe, and a whopping 96% of them gave it 5 stars.

99% of owners gave it 4&5-star ratings, with the combined score of an excellent 4.9 stars.

 

THE Industry standard for decades

Concept2 Model D rowers set the industry standard of excellence in both design & durability.

This top-rated rowing machine will outlast any of the others, and deliver a smooth, high quality rowing workout.

 

Very easy to assemble

All it took was: insert around 8 screws, join the middle parts, and boom…done.

 

Concept2 rowers: Made in the USA since 1981

There is no substitute for expert experience and fine craftsmanship & design, and Concept2 has nearly 40 years’ worth.

 

Concept2 storage

Putting it away if need be is a simple operation.

It has wheels and it doesn’t weigh very much – just 57 lb. – so it’s easy to move somewhere.

You just separate it into two pieces and off you roll.

 

Advanced performance monitor

The Concept2 Model D console comes with multiple features galore, like competitions, online connecting to CrossFit® WODs & other workout challenge groups, etc.

The monitor provides exportable data that has stat graphs, your workout history, & more.

It can connect to a bunch of different popular fitness apps too.

All this, and….it’s easy to program & use.

 

Bluetooth heart monitoring

The Concept2 has a heart rate monitor that works via Bluetooth.

And it’s actually accurate, unlike the heart rate monitors found on the majority of imported fitness equipment.

 

Smart engineering

A couple of thoughtful ergonomic design choices are the size-adjustable footrest and the small angle built into the rowing handle.

Given the amount of strokes we log when rowing, anything that puts body parts in a stress-less position throughout the rowing motion is a real good idea.

 

Very high weight capacity

One indication of how sturdy the Concept2 rower is: its max user weight is 500 lb.

 

Cooling fan

The fan that supplies you with the air resistance is kindly designed to blow it your way while you’re working out.

Feels good when you get all steamed up after awhile…

 

Free shipping on Amazon

 

Possible issues for some people:

  • It’s not a cheap rower
  • It’s not a compact rowing machine – it’s 8 feet long
  • It’s not quiet, due to the air fan’s resistance

 

Concept2 Model D technical specifications

  • Resistance type: Air
  • Max user weight: 500 lb.
  • Dimensions: 96”L x 24”W x 45”H
  • Separated for storage dimensions: 33”L x 25”W x 54”H
  • Steel slide rail & frame
  • Multiple function performance monitor
  • Exportable data capability and fitness app compatibility
  • Heart rate monitor works via Bluetooth
  • Concept2 Model D weight: 57 lb.
  • Warranty: 5 years frame, 2 years parts

See reviews & current price on Amazon

 

rowing machine orange - heydayDo icon icon

 

#2 The Best Water Rowing Machine

WaterRower Club Rowing Machine, Ash Wood

Owner satisfaction rating 91% 4.6⭐, 800+ online reviews

The WaterRower is one of the top-rated home rowing machines out there, and it’s the best water rower by far.

 

WaterRower Club Rowing Machine in Ash Wood - heydayDo image copy

 

Premium quality construction, it is hand-built out of Ash wood and hand-finished with Danish oil & urethane.

Plus it used to be a TV star: it was the rowing machine featured on Netflix’ House of Cards.

The wooden rowing machine frame helps absorb any mechanical noise.

 

A pleasant experience

So what you hear most is your paddles ‘pulling’ water in the tank located down near the end of the WaterRower.

All this makes this water rowing machine workout very aesthetically pleasing.

The WaterRower Club rower is an attractive display piece in your home and when you’re done, you can stand it up along a wall and call it art.

 

What I like about the WaterRower

 

Hand-built

Hand-built with quality in the USA with longevity firmly in mind, made by a very good company that backs up their product.

 

Very quiet 

The WaterRower Club’s wood design choice keeps it very quiet and looks beautiful too.

And if you’re environmentally conscious, you’ll like that WaterRower gets their wood from sustainably-managed forests.

 

Assembly is easy

It’s easier than I expected for some reason, and the instructions are real clear.

(What a nice surprise, compared to dealing with the owner’s manual & required assembly for a couple of those cheap imported rowing machines). 

I’m guesstimating it’ll take 30 minutes or less for most people.

 

Just like you’re on a lake

Unsurprisingly, the WaterRower rowing stroke has the same natural motion & feel of rowing on the water, with the same sequence of legs & upper body work.

This is what all rowing machines want to feel like (but most don’t of course).

 

Very good monitor

The WaterRower Club model’s workout console is called the S4 performance monitor, and it is easy to see and easy to use.

It is also much more advanced than what you’ll find on most other rowing machines.

It has multiple ways to store and program your own workout programs, and it accurately keeps track of several data points generated during your rowing sessions.

This also includes an advanced set of heart rate stats too.

By the way, all of the WaterRower’s performance monitor data is exportable to your computer or elsewhere online.

 

Great warranty

Solid owner protection provided by WaterRower, offering plenty of time for you to find out if anything’s not built to their high standard: 5 years for the frame, 3 years for the parts.

 

Training DVD included

The WaterRower ships with an at-home rowing machine training DVD, owner’s manual, a siphoning pump, water purification tablets, and an Allen wrench.

 

Assembly vids available

On WaterRower’s website, they have assembly videos if you’d like to lean on those instead of reading through the manual’s instructions.

 

Connect to rowing workout apps

There are free software downloads to connect you to other rowers and training programs: NetAthlon, WeRow, & Coxswain.

And if you’d like to take your workout tracking to the next level, there’s a software called SmartRow you can install.

This will integrate with the SmartRow app on your iOS & Android devices.

 

Add-ons & upgrades

There are a variety of accessories & upgrades you can buy to embellish your WaterRower experience: wooden stands & arms for your laptop, tablet, & phone, mats, cover, etc.

 

Shipping is currently free on Amazon

 

Possible issues for some people:

  • Price may be out of reach
  • It’s long; you’ll need a footprint of 8’ x 3’ or so
  • It’s pretty low to the ground, when bought as-is**

This probably won’t bother most people I’m sure.

(I’ve had to manage pain from a L4/L5 herniated disc for 20+ years. Certain simple moves to the floor can require a bit of “creative thinking” whenever nerve pain is lurking around, for those of us with low-back injuries.)

 

**But in any event, WaterRower does sell an add-on product called the Hi-Rise – it’s basically two wooden stands you attach to the frame of your rowing machine.

They’ll raise it 8”, which would actually make a big difference for some of us.

 

WaterRower technical specifications

  • Resistance type: Water
  • Max user weight: 750 lb.
  • Dimensions: 82”L x 22”W x 20”H
  • Folded dimensions: (It doesn’t fold; it stands upright at 6′ 10″ H)
  • WaterRower weight: 67 lb. without water, 104 lb. with
  • Warranty: 5 years frame, 3 years parts

See reviews & current price on Amazon

 

rowing machine orange - heydayDo icon icon

 

#3 The Best Magnetic Rowing Machine

Fitness Reality 4000MR Rowing Machine

Owner satisfaction rating 94% 4.8⭐, 30+ online reviews (brand new model)

A new and formidable competitor to the former top home rower with magnetic resistance, the Stamina Avari.

 

Fitness Reality 4000MR Magnetic Rower Rowing Machine - heydayDo image copy

 

For a few years, the Stamina Avari (reviewed later in this article) had generally been considered the best magnetic rowing machine available, despite its flaws & weak warranty.

Its owner satisfaction ratings were never nearly as good as Concept2’s or WaterRower’s, but the Stamina Avari simply didn’t have any magnetic resistance competition.

 

Until recently that is.

 

First Schwinn retooled, revamped, & renamed their lone rower, now known as the Crewmaster (also reviewed here).

It has fewer dissatisfied customers than the Stamina Avari, and about the same percentage that love it.

 

And now here’s Fitness Reality’s entry into the mid-priced market

The Fitness Reality 4000MR is a brand-new model that came out in 2019.

And in the ensuing months since then, the owner reviews that have trickled in have been overwhelmingly positive – it boasts a 94% owner satisfaction rating at this time.

 

Now, I may be a bit premature in crowning it the Best Magnetic Rowing Machine, since it’s not even been on the market for a year yet.

 

But so far it has no glaring problems and no 1&2-star dissatisfied owners, unlike the Stamina Avari with nearly 1 in 5 owners unhappy with their purchase.

Plus the Fitness Reality 4000MR has other superior qualities to it – including an excellent warranty – that warrant me giving it the #1 spot for magnetic resistance rowing machines, in my mind anyway.

 

What I like about the Fitness Reality MR4000

Great warranty

A good warranty says a lot about what the company thinks of their product. Come to think of it, a bad warranty does the same.

Fitness Reality’s warranty protection for their 4000MR is:

  • 5 years for the frame
  • 3 years for most parts
  • 2 years for the electronics & the wearable parts

By contrast, the Stamina Avari warranty is 3 years for the frame, 3 months for parts.

In my opinion, 90 days isn’t a very long time to stand by the pieces you built into your exercise equipment I just paid around 700 bucks for.

 

Assembly is easy enough

I didn’t build this one myself, but several owners have commented on their assembly process going smoothly, thanks to very clear instructions & thoughtful parts packaging.

A couple of people who both said they were not mechanically inclined at all each assembled theirs in 90 minutes or so.

 

A smooth, quiet, & more natural rowing stroke

The 4000MR has arms that operate like a boat’s oars, in that they work independently from each other.

This makes for a more natural, wider range of motion compared to the fixed position handle on most rowing machines, and adds to the comfort equation.

As I mention later, magnetic resistance is the quietest type of rowing machine resistance, and the sliding along the rail is smooth & quiet as well, thanks to the design choice to use ball bearings in the seat rollers.

 

Raised height of seat

Many rowing machines are set quite low to the ground, and climbing aboard can create a challenge for some of us with mobility issues or low-back pain.

The 4000MR’s seat is mounted several inches higher than most rowers, and is in the neighborhood of 21″-23″ off the ground.

That’s a thoughtful design that’ll be a big help to a number of people.

The seat felt comfortable to me too; it’s not hard like some, and has a little “cush-ness” to it.

 

Console is programmable, easy to use & easy to see

The screen is plenty big enough to clearly read the info, and it is backlit so it can be used in dim lighting.

It’s angle can be adjusted to suit any user’s line of sight.

It comes with several (10 I think) pre-programmed workouts, and you can also program up to 5 of your own.

The controls on the monitor are simple to use, and it displays all of the usual workout stats you’d expect.

 

Foot pedals & straps

This might not seem like much I admit.

But I like the fact that the 4000MR has foot pedals that are big enough for my shoe size (11.5, 4E wide).

That foot size isn’t even that big, but some mid-priced & cheap pieces of exercise equipment use pedals & footrests that are just too small to deal with.

Also, the 4000MR’s straps have enough adjustability in them to get a comfortable, snug fit.

 

Miscellaneous

A few other little things:

  • Wheels for rolling – nice, since it weighs over 100 lb.
  • Phone tray
  • Folds down a little, to approx. 4’L x 2’W x 5’H
  • Console runs on electricity (vs. the usual battery-powered)

 

Possible issues for some people:

  • It weighs 116 lb., which might seem a bit heavy to some
  • Magnetic resistance doesn’t replicate real rowing resistance
  • Therefore it’s not suitable for the hardcore athlete

 

Fitness Reality 4000MR technical specifications

  • Resistance type: Magnetic
  • Max user weight: 300 lb.
  • User height range: 5′ – 6′ 5″
  • Dimensions: 72”L x 25”W x 51”H
  • Folded dimensions: 45″L x 25″W x 51″H
  • 4000MR weight: 116 lb.
  • Warranty: 5 years frame, 3 years parts, 2 years electronics & wearable parts

See reviews & current price on Amazon

 

rowing machine orange - heydayDo icon icon

 

 

#4 An Affordable Magnetic Rowing Machine

Schwinn Crewmaster Rowing Machine

Owner satisfaction rating 74% 4.2⭐, 70+ online reviews

This Schwinn rower is a decent mid-priced magnetic rowing machine with a very good warranty behind it.

 

Schwinn Crewmaster Rowing Machine - heydayDo image copy

 

It’s quiet like other magnetic rowers, and has a sturdy, stable feel, thanks to the frame & rail being made of steel.

It’s monitor is large and easy to see & use, but it lacks programming capability.

The Schwinn Crewmaster rowing machine does have 10 resistance levels that you adjust manually.

 

Limitations of magnetic resistance

It has the same, unchanging resistance ‘feel’ during the entire drive portion of the stroke, just like other magnetic rowing machines. 

This means the Schwinn Crewmaster rower doesn’t match up to real water rowing or an air resistance flywheel like Concept2’s Model D

As a result, the Crewmaster is better suited for light intensity rowing machine workouts by casual users, versus any hardcore HIIT or similarly athletic routines performed by stronger fitness types.

 

What I like about the Schwinn Crewmaster

Very good warranty – for an affordably-priced rowing machine

Easy to see & use console – large LCD monitor that’s height adjustable

Ergonomic – footrests, seat, & handle are all ergonomically A-OK

Very quiet – like a good magnetic rowing machine’s supposed to be

Consistent action – smooth motion throughout stroke

Sturdy feel – Stable & sturdy, no wobble or vibrating

Multiple resistance – 10 resistance levels, adjusted manually

Rolls – Has a set of wheels for rolling

Shipping free on Amazon

 

Possible issues for some people:

* The Schwinn rower is a full-sized model at nearly 8′ long

* The monitor is not programmable nor does it have any built-in training programs

* The warranty is real good, no doubt about it.

Howeverit is important to be aware that their marketing literature says (on Amazon & elsewhere) “10-year frame, 3-year parts and 1-year labor”, but the fine print in the Schwinn Crewmaster actual warranty says “Wear Parts – 6 months

* The Schwinn Crewmaster rower advertises it is enabled for heart rate monitoring, but you have to separately buy a Polar® brand non-coded chest strap to be able to use that function (they’re around $35 right now)

 

Schwinn Crewmaster technical specifications

  • Resistance type: Magnetic
  • Nylon transmission cable
  • Steel slide rail
  • Max user weight: 300 lb.
  • Dimensions: 93″L x 21″W x 32″H
  • Folded dimensions:   51”L x 21”W x 61”H
  • Schwinn Crewmaster weight: 75 lb.
  • Warranty: 10y frame, 3y mechanical & electronic parts, 6 mos. “wear” parts, 1y labor

See reviews & current price on Amazon

 

rowing machine orange - heydayDo icon icon

 

#5 Another Magnetic Rowing Machine

Stamina Avari Magnetic Rower

Owner satisfaction rating 74% 4.1⭐, 200+ online reviews

This Avari rowing machine from Stamina Fitness has many features and is in the upper-mid price range of rowers.

Note: Stamina recently hiked it up to around $700, without making any improvements to it.

 

Stamina Avari Programmable Magnetic Exercise Rower - heydayDo image copy

 

It offers better resistance than cheaper magnetic rowers, and the build feels pretty sturdy to me.

The 3-year warranty on the frame validates that feeling somewhat.

The workout monitor offers several preset programs, plus you can store your own.

 

It also comes with a wireless heart monitor and with a program that’ll guide you for heart rate targets in your workout.

It’s very quiet, folds down to a decent size, and can be wheeled somewhere fairly easily.

 

Owner satisfaction is pretty good at 74%, but it has fallen somewhat in the past couple of years.

The short warranty on parts is a negative for me, since I’m big on warranties.

 

What I like about the Stamina Avari

 

Easy to assemble

Very quiet

Solid – Aluminum frame feels solid, and the frame has a nice warranty with it too

Adjust on the fly – Electronic adjustable resistance can be done while working out, so no need to stop

Good resistance – The Stamina Avari has a better resistance profile than other magnetic rowing machines I’ve tried

Multiple programs – A dozen training programs to choose from in the monitor. You can create your own and save them as well

Chest strap heart monitor – Has a remote heart monitoring program with an included chest strap. Other rowers with heart monitoring make you buy your own chest strap (they’re $35-$85)

Easy storage – Easy to fold and pretty easy to roll around on its wheels

Shipping free on Amazon

 

Possible issues for some people:

* It has a nylon transmission/pull strap and I’m a little leery of those. But…the nylon strap on this Avari rowing machine is a little bigger/thicker than others I’ve seen

* Short warranty on parts. This will crop up a with many other home rowing machines you come across too.

I just don’t like a manufacturer charging “X” hundreds of dollars (in this Stamina Avari case, close to $700), and then offering to stand by the parts in their rowing machine for only 90 days.

* A few owners have reported defective out-of-the-box or early malfunctioning of the computer monitor

* The seat isn’t real comfortable for my butt – I think 30 minutes on it several times a week wouldn’t be nice without adding a cushion of some sort

* My guess is these velcro straps on the footrests won’t last real long

 

Stamina Avari technical specifications

  • Resistance type: Magnetic
  • Max user weight capacity: 275 lb.
  • Aluminum slide rail
  • Dimensions: 81”L x 20”W x 25”H
  • Folded dimensions: 36”L x 20”W x 23”H
  • Stamina Avari weight: 75 lb.
  • Warranty: 3y frame, 90 days parts

See reviews & current price on Amazon

rowing machine green - heydayDo icon

 

 

#6 A quiet home rower for low-impact cardio

LifeSpan Fitness RW 1000 Rowing Machine

Owner satisfaction rating 65% 3.7⭐, 100+ reviews

The mid-priced LifeSpan RW1000 rowing machine is probably best suited for someone who is new to exercise or rowing, and not a hardcore exercise buff.

 

LifeSpan RW1000 Indoor Rowing Machine - heydayDo image copy

 

Still, it has a great warranty considering its price.

And so this LifeSpan rower could potentially provide years of satisfactory cardio workouts to someone looking for a quiet, convenient, space-saving & low-impact workout at home.

However, the RW1000 has one too many manufacturing flaws and unsatisfied owners for me to recommend it to anyone, though it does have a few nice qualities to it.

The poor showing of this rower is a bit surprising, considering that LifeSpan Fitness makes some very high-quality fitness products that perform great for years.

 

What I like about the Lifespan RW1000

Lifespan RW1000 - Best Rowing Machine - heydayDo image

Very good warranty for a relatively inexpensive rowing machine

Easy assembly

Quiet enough for apartment dwellers

Nice seat – It’s comfortable and height adjustable (11” – 14.5”)

Decent monitor – A very basic console that’s easy to see, easy to use. And it runs on 2 AAA batteries, so no need for a power cord/outlet

Multiple resistance – 5 adjustment levels of resistance with an easy-to-reach knob

Folding is a breeze – and the LifeSpan RW1000 has decent wheels if you need to roll it off to the side somewhere

Shipping free on Amazon

 

Possible issues for some people:

* I don’t think the LifeSpan RW 1000 offers enough resistance for someone who can push decent weight around in a gym.

I felt that the highest resistance level would provide me a good cardio workout, but not stress my muscle strength as much as other rowers

* A few owners report that the front of the LifeSpan rower lifts off the ground or moves during their drive/pull motion.

When I tried it out I rowed smooth & far from all-out effort (I was at a store with the clerk standing near me toe-tapping). I kept the pull cord pretty horizontal, and it didn’t lift on me

* Console has no training program presets and no user options for programming either

* The footrests seem small to me (me: size 11.5, 4E wide), and the straps seemed a bit flimsy too; didn’t keep my feet snug to the footrests.

Maybe the floor model I was on was old.

Some owners reported similar issues, and a few had their foot straps break off entirely

* I saw a couple of reports that the LifeSpan rowers had consoles that were defective out of the box or failed within a short period of time

 

Lifespan RW1000 technical specifications

  • Resistance type: Magnetic
  • Max user weight: 300 lb.
  • Nylon (or equivalent) pull cord
  • Steel slide rail
  • Dimensions: 87”L x 19”W x 23”H
  • Folded dimensions: 34″L x 19″W x 64″H
  • LifeSpan RW1000 weight: 75 lb.
  • Warranty: 5y frame, 2y parts, 1y labor

See reviews & current price on Amazon

 

 

Rowing Machine Resistance Types 

Smiling woman doing her rowing workout on a top rowing machine - heydayDo image

 

 

As previously mentioned, there are four types of resistance found in rowing machines:

  • Air
  • Water
  • Magnetic
  • Hydraulic

 

Air Rowers & Water Rowing Machines

Air rowers & water rower machines provide a smoother, more natural motion than hydraulic or magnetic rowing machines.

Air rowers and water rowing machines also deliver a superior workout, because they will naturally provide more resistance as you stroke harder.

You will not see professional or collegiate athletes – nor serious workout people – using a hydraulic or magnetic rowing machine to train on.

Air rowers, and in particular Concept2’s Model D & Model E, are overwhelmingly the preferred rowing machine of choice for women & men dedicated to their fitness.

Air rowers make more noise than all other rowing machines, since you’re driving a giant fan that’s pulling in air as you stroke.

Water rowers are very quiet. The only noises you’ll hear are the sound of your paddles against the water in the rowing machine’s tank, and a little of your seat moving on the slide rail.

 

Magnetic Rowing Machines

Magnetic rowing machines are very quiet since there’s no air or water being pulled.

They provide resistance with a braking system that uses magnets against the flywheel.

As you adjust the resistance the magnet moves closer or further away from the flywheel.

The workout quality is not as good as with an air rower or water rowing machine.

This has to do with the way magnetic resistance works during the entire rowing motion.

 

Not as tough as the best rowing machines

The best magnetic rowing machines are also inferior to top-rated air & water rowers when it comes to durability.

A quick look at most magnetic rowing machines’ warranty – typically offering only 90 days of protection on parts – will tell you that.

The Fitness Reality 4000MR (2 years), Lifespan RW1000 (2 years), and Schwinn (6 months) reviewed here are exceptions.

 

On the other hand, I have seen many Concept2 rowers in commercial gyms that were still in action after more than a decade of being used morning, noon, & night by thousands of people.

 

rowing machine brown - heydayDO icon

 

Hydraulic Rowing Machines

The final type of rower resistance there is uses hydraulic pistons.

It is an inexpensive design decision by the manufacturer, so you’ll see many of the cheap rowing machines (those under $300) use hydraulic resistance.

 

The hydraulic pistons are attached to arms that you row with, and the fluid inside them resists your effort like those things you see attached to screen doors to keep them from slamming.

Or like a shock absorber that prevents your car body from bouncing off the ground or onto your tires every time you go over a bump or a hole.

 

Hydraulic rowers have design flaws

Hydraulics being inexpensive is nice, but because they’re cheap know that they’re not going to last anywhere near as long as a well-built air or water rower.

Also – this design with its mechanical arms causes the natural rowing motion to be lost.

So your arms are moving and your legs are moving, but you’re not using your muscles in the same way as you would be if you were using a belt-driven air, water, or magnetic rowing machine. Or a row boat.

Another problem with hydraulic fluid is that if it’s too cold, the resistance will be unnaturally too stiff.

And when it gets too hot you lose all resistance entirely.

You can overheat it simply by working out with some effort for 20-30 minutes.

And until it cools down some, it won’t be usable.

Since they’re not built tough and can’t go for long cardio sessions, hydraulic rowing machines are better suited for beginning exercisers and people who aren’t real fit or physically strong.

 

 

Concluding my home rowing machine review

Boy rowing on lake at sunset

OK, time to sail away row away into the sunset here.

I hope my home rowing machine product recon & research was helpful to you, and that my rowing machine buyer’s guide information was useful too.

A home rower is a great & convenient way to take advantage of the benefits a rowing machine workout provides.

(I didn’t go into detail about it here, but a HIIT rowing machine workout plan can really deliver fitness results, in just a few minutes a day too.)

I wish you well on your fitness journey; let’s go.

– greg

January 2021

 

« Home Fitness Equipment page

 


About heydayDo

heydayDo author Greg Simon
Hi I’m Greg Simon. Fitness training & nutrition researching since 1982. Organic food & wine grower. Surfer. Congenital heart disease survivor (so far). Read more…
heydayDo is my “fitness after 50” website that’s about embracing the physically active lifestyle as we get older.
 
I write about the fitness and health research I’ve found concerning the quality of life benefits that exercise and good nutrition provide.
 
When I get curious about something, I’ll dig into whatever sports science & medical facts there are on the topic to learn what’s real & what’s only hype. I also post my experiences product-testing & evaluating home gym equipment & fitness supplements.
 
 It’s an information-sharing, personal opinion blog of mine.
 
So if you’re looking for medical or nutritional advice, please consult with your doctor or health professional for that, since heydayDo does not provide medical advice.